girlie jones (girliejones) wrote,
girlie jones
girliejones

Its the conversation we keep having to have

So, I'm not that much interested in the Mind Melds over at SF Signal. You can probably guess why but jonathanstrahan pointed it out to me yesterday and I meant to post this yesterday but ran out of time.

So this one is on the Single Author Collections everybody needs to have aka the ones most worthy of us discussing. And in summary:

Elizabeth Anne Hull puts forward just 3 titles, all men.
Jeff Vandermeer gives us 10 female titles and a bunch more in his "what else I could have said"
Mike Resnick gives us 9 men and one 1 woman
Catherynne Valente gives us two women
John Ottinger III gives a bunch of men and Elizabeth Moon
Alvaro Zinos-Amaro gives us 9 men and one 1 woman writing as a man
Dave Truesdale gives us a complete list of men.

Of the 7 people asked in this first part, 2 were women.

Much of what I would have to say about this, I've already said before. In brief, to male commentators, women writers in the field are invisible.

What I do have to say is thanks Jeff Vandermeer - by making his own statement loud and clear he has acted as a true critic for me, and given me a huge bunch of books to add to my own reading list, something you don't nornally get with these because people list the obvious and known. He has told ME what should be on MY reading list and in MY library. *APPLAUDS*

Tags: breaking through the glass ceiling of sf, feminism
Subscribe

  • Back home

    Phew. Today was crazy. I didn't sleep more than 4 hours, up late talking to jonathanstrahan and then listening to my ipod. I emerged…

  • Very last of the Tasmanians

    So um, my fly by drunk post last night totally skipped a bunch of stuff. We had much to celebrate last night and I really enjoyed the first few…

  • Last night in Hobart and Tasmania

    Here I am, its 1am, I am wide eye awake - alcohol does that to me (I've tried to tell maelkann this before but he doesn't believe me).…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 16 comments

  • Back home

    Phew. Today was crazy. I didn't sleep more than 4 hours, up late talking to jonathanstrahan and then listening to my ipod. I emerged…

  • Very last of the Tasmanians

    So um, my fly by drunk post last night totally skipped a bunch of stuff. We had much to celebrate last night and I really enjoyed the first few…

  • Last night in Hobart and Tasmania

    Here I am, its 1am, I am wide eye awake - alcohol does that to me (I've tried to tell maelkann this before but he doesn't believe me).…